Skip to content

Testing if your CSS partner cannibalises your own Shopping campaigns using brand-exclusion

If your own Shopping campaigns and a CSS partner both advertise the same products, are you paying the partner for sales you would have made anyway? It’s a fair question, as both bid in the same auctions.

Shoparize team E-commerce growth team

Introduction

If your own Shopping campaigns and a CSS partner both advertise the same products, are you paying the partner for sales you would have made anyway? It’s a fair question, as both bid in the same auctions.

For Koffievoordeel, Shoparize ran a brand-exclusion test to answer this question in roughly seven weeks: five weeks of unrestricted, then 15 days with brand searches removed. Koffievoordeel.nl ran the test with us using their own data.

Reviewing CSS overlap with a brand-exclusion

The brand-exclusion test tracks three numbers:

  1. Order-level interaction. For each sale the partner brings in, check whether the buyer clicked on your own Shopping ads before buying. If they didn’t, your own ads had no part in that sale. If they did, both you and the partner were involved, and the partner may be taking credit for a sale your ad helped win.
  2. New-customer share. Check how many of the partner’s buyers are new to your shop, then compare with your other channels. If most of its buyers are existing customers, that’s a sign of an overlap. If it brings in more new customers than your other channels, it’s reaching people you weren’t reaching.
  3. Overlap rate. How often your own ads show up in the same searches as the partner’s ads. That tells you how much of the partner’s activity sits on searches you already cover.

Before your campaign starts, agree on these three measurements, together with everyone involved: your PPC team, your affiliate team if the partnership runs through a network, your agency if there is one, and the partner. Everyone then judges the results by the same numbers. Koffievoordeel.nl followed this approach, then reviewed one shared dashboard every week, with data on search terms, products and orders.

What does a brand-exclusion mean in practice?

Brand searches are searches that include your shop’s name, such as “koffievoordeel”. People searching for you by name already know you; it is common for merchants to assume that that’s where a sale they would have made anyway is taken by the partner. The brand-exclusion tests whether this is true.

Let the partner’s campaigns run for five weeks with no restrictions, so you know the starting point for daily conversions, new-customer share and overlap rate. Then exclude all brand search terms and their misspellings from the partner’s campaigns for 15 days and change nothing else.

During this period, watch your own Shopping campaigns. If your own campaigns win the sales your CSS partner lost, it means you would have won these orders anyway. If they don’t, the partner was bringing you extra orders that your own ads couldn’t get.

The brand-exclusion test is just one of four ways to measure the extra sales your CSS partner brings. Learn the other three in The CSS Incrementality Playbook.

Koffievoordeel.nl ran the test, and decided to keep brand-searches on in their CSS partner’s campaigns

Koffievoordeel.nl, part of e-Luscious, sells coffee online in the Netherlands. Competitors with bigger budgets had increased their ad presence in the Dutch online coffee market. To compete without increasing its own ad budget, the shop wanted a CSS partner paid only on sales, working through Adtraction. The affiliate team is measured on new customers, and the PPC team runs its own Shopping campaigns, both needed proof that the partner would bring sales the shop wouldn’t have made otherwise. It ran the brand-exclusion test with Shoparize as its CSS partner.

The test ran from 5 to 19 February, after the five unrestricted weeks. Compared with the starting point:

  • Daily conversions fell by 41%.
  • New-customer share rose from 43% to 47%, a four-point gain.
  • Koffievoordeel.nl’s own campaigns only partly took over the ad space Shoparize gave up.
  • Overlap rate rose from 81.3% to 86.2%. Without brand searches, Shoparize’s remaining ads showed mostly on general coffee searches, where the shop’s own ads also appeared. That doesn’t push up the price: when both bid on the same product, Google only uses the higher bid, and the price is set by a competing shop.

Removing brand searches cut the partner’s daily sales by 41%, and barely changed who the campaign reached, so on 20 February brand terms went back on for good. During the whole campaign, 89% of Shoparize-driven orders came from buyers who never clicked on Koffievoordeel.nl’s own Shopping ads.

From January to September 2026, 43% of orders Shoparize drove came from new customers, compared with 23% across Koffievoordeel.nl’s affiliate channel as a whole. 31% of those new customers bought again within 16 weeks. Once the test had proved that the partner was bringing extra sales, Koffievoordeel.nl let Shoparize raise bids through the quiet Dutch summer. In early September, daily orders reached their highest level since January.

“CSS provides a strong, always-on source of new customers with good customer quality and limited overlap with SEA. At the same time, we work on a CPO basis, with Shoparize covering the media costs, which limits the financial risk for us.”

Rijk van Schaick

Ready to improve your Shopping performance?

Tell us what you want to improve and we will point you to the right Shoparize path.

Get started
Shoparize team E-commerce growth team at Shoparize.